Israel seeks return of Temple artifacts from the Vatican

Some years ago, while reading about the Knights Templars, I stumbled upon a close-up picture of the famous relief which is part of the sculptured Arch of Titus, (Arcus Titi) erected in Rome, depicting the capture of Jerusalem by the Romans, in A.D. 70. And that image of the pillage of our Holy Temple has stayed with me all these years.

The entire arch can be seen here, while another closeup of the inside jamb of the arch, depicting the victors carrying off the treasures of the Temple can be seen here. Evidently, the Arch of Titus tickled many people’s imaginations. A small version of a painting of the Arch of Titus, now being displayed on this page, shows the northern arch only, by three painters, George Peter Alexander Healy, Frederic E. Church, Jervis McEntee, who wanted to create a memento of their experience in Italy together.

In the closeup of the southern arch is the relief representing the spoils from the temple at Jerusalem; the table of shewbread, the seven-branched candlestick, and the silver trumpets, which are being carried in triumph into the city.

Well, yesterday, Israel’s chief rabbis, Yehuda Metzger and Shlomo Amar, were scheduled to meet Pope John Paul II, and to seek permission to search Vatican storerooms for artifacts such as the huge golden menorah that stood in the Temple in Jerusalem 2,000 years ago.

When the Romans sacked Jerusalem in AD 70, they took Temple treasures with them. Legend has it that religious articles from the Temple, including the menorah, were among them. Amar said the Vatican has already denied the menorah is there.

An aide to the rabbi said the Vatican was not likely to permit a search. The Vatican will allow the rabbis to view rare Jewish manuscripts in its possession, Amar said. He said if the rabbis were to come across “other objects,” they would be happy to bring them home.

The Maariv newspaper in Israel said the two rabbis could also seek to buy back a candelabrum that came from the Temple. It is believed to be held in the Vatican’s vast treasure caves.

In 1996, in the face of criticism and skepticism, Israeli Religious Affairs Minister Shimon Shetreet requested of the pope that an official inquiry be conducted to determine if the legendary golden menorah from the Second Temple is hidden in the Vatican.

Shetreet claimed to have evidence the menorah was there, though he refused to disclose it. He did say he had statements of people who claimed to have had discussions with previous popes, who indicated that the Catholic Church indeed did have such objects.

But, is the menorah depicted on Titus’ Arch the same menorah that was used in the Temple?

When the Maccabees returned to the desecrated Temple they found that much of its wealth and splendor had been plundered by the Greeks. Among the artifacts that had been stolen by Antiochos was the golden candelabrum, likely the same one that had been fashioned by the returning Babylonian exiles in the time of Ezra and Nehemiah. Until a new candelabrum could be crafted, the soldiers improvised a makeshift device out of hollowed spearheads. Only later was a new golden replica manufactured, which was probably lit at the official rededication of the purified Temple, the first Chanukah.

The representation of the candelabrum on Hasmonean coins depicted here and here provides one of the oldest pictures of the Menorah. One notable feature of that depiction is that it seems to be standing on a sort of tripod. This would agree with the evidence of the Talmud (which speaks of an indeterminate number of “legs”), as well as with the three-legged Menorah images that were incorporated in much of Jewish art in later centuries.

This portrayal of a Menorah supported by a tripod base is not the one that springs most naturally to our minds. Most of us imagine the Menorah with a broad, solid base, like the one that appears in the official seal of the State of Israel. The source for this image is the Arch of Titus, and the Menorah is perhaps the most prominent of the treasures. However the base of Titus’ Menorah is not a tripod, but the now-familiar two-tiered hexagonal structure.

There are many factors that testify to the authenticity of the depiction in Titus’ arch: In general, Roman triumphal arches were designed as historical documents and towards that end strove to be as accurate as possible. In this case, almost all the details demonstrate to the sculptors’ intimate knowledge of the Temple’s vessels as described in the Bible and other Jewish sources.

How then are we to explain the discrepancy between two different renderings of the Menorah’s base?

Some clues to this are suggested in ornamental designs that appear in Titus’ Menorah. A similar base has been excavated from a Roman temple at Didymus, now in southern Turkey.

There are some striking differences between Titus’ candelabrum and its pagan counterparts. The Didymus lamp features a human figure seated on the back of the monster. It also portrays this creature with spikes coming from its neck, an image that was explicitly prohibited by Talmudic law. Both these features are lacking in the image of the Temple Menorah.

This fact might account for the absence of the Menorah from the coinage of the Jewish rebellions in 69-70 and 135, which made much use of other symbols from the Temple worship.

When the Menorah did regain popularity as a decorative theme in Jewish art from the third century onwards, it was the original three legged lamp that was chosen.

So, the question remains: Is the menorah depicted on Titus’ Arch the same menorah that was used in the Temple?

But more importantly, does the Vatican still possess artifacts of the Temple? If the Vatican does not, what happened to our Temple’s treasures?

Fortunately, the majority of readers of this poll, Should Vatican return Temple treasures to Jews? chose “Yes, artifacts rightfully belong to Israel”.

Smooth Stone gratefully acknowledges Ohr Sameyach for their research and Folger’s delicious coffee for providing me with the energy I needed to write this article.

Comments 24

  1. Emma Ekwonna Youth Empowerment Foundation (EEYEF)

    Attn: Sir,
    Calvary greetings from Emma Ekwonna Youth Empowerment Foundation (aka EEYEF), a non-political party or political organization/movement, a non- governmental, not- for- profit, but a self-help organization established here in Nigeria with the aim of training and empowering women, youths, disabled persons, Orphans and Vulnerable Children (OVC) to help bring peace in Nigeria to the society at large.
    Training and empowering women helps to reduce the spread of HIV/AIDS, reduce the rate of moral crimes like prostitution/capital crimes which is against the teachings of God, reduce domestic violence, create employment, aid women to participate in politics and decision making in Nigeria hence they contribute positively to the economy of the nation (gender equality).
    Training and empowering youths helps to reduce the spread of HIV/AIDS, reduce crimes like violence, thuggery, touting, prostitution, kidnapping/hostage-taking, armed robbery, drug abuse/peddling and other unwholesome activities.
    Training and empowering disabled persons help to give them sense of belonging in the society. It also helps to reduce the spread of HIV/AIDS and they will contribute to the economic growth of the nation.
    Fairing for Orphans and Vulnerable Children OVC’s helps them to grow to be useful in life and society at large.
    It is based on the above that EEYEF as a humanitarian organization was set up to see how these sets of human beings can be reached positively.
    Generally, this humanitarian organization was established to help the teaming youths, women and disabled persons in Nigeria who have no good means of livelihood, to give them hope in life which will make them to shun all manners of evil practices like violence, thuggery, touting, prostitution, kidnapping/hostage-taking and other fraudulent activities. It is a fact that the world is afraid of HIV/AIDS and wants to stop it, UN has brought out a lot of measures like awareness campaign to stop the spread of HIV/AIDS but neglecting the agents of the spread which is idle youths and women, but when empowered, it will reduce the spread of this pandemic. From the research we made, will discovered that about 98% of the spread of the virus is through idle women and youths in every society. No doubts “Idle mind is the devil’s workshop.”
    EEYEF have researched and discovered that a lot of women and youths both graduates and non-graduates are lackadaisical to look for job or engage in any meaningful employment, since there is scarcity of white collar jobs in Nigeria and they have no vocational training. This has made them to loose focus in life and increase violence and the spread of HIV/AIDS.
    In any case, this could be stopped and these groups of people will have hope in life. This can only be achieved by training and empowering women, youths and disabled persons.
    EEYEF goes out to identify the women, youths and disabled persons who actually are interested to learn any vocation of their choice to enable them have a meaningful livelihood and shun violence. We do this through the help of the media (Radio/ TV announcements and Newspapers), churches and religious bodies, Local Governments, Village heads and traditional rulers, youth organizations, seminars and workshops. We make forms available and call for people to come and collect forms free of charge. In the form, we list a number of vocations and the candidate will mark the one he or she is interested in learning. EEYEF will take that particular candidate to the place where he or she can stay to learn the work as an apprentice for agreed period of time, pay the required fee and the candidate will start to learn the work. Every month, EEYEF provides the beneficiary with stipend to aid his/her transportation for the month.
    Within this period, EEYEF coordinator goes from time to time to monitor the candidate and to ask in secret the relationship between the candidate and his/ her boss/instructor. After the agreed period, if the boss certifies that the candidate has actually learned and known the vocation, EEYEF empowers the candidate with initial working tools to start on his own. When the candidates are established, they will follow to train subsequent applicants (Train the Trainer). Our target groups are women, youth and disabled persons, both graduates and non-graduate.
    Our aim is to make sure that within a few years; the rate of unemployment is reduced and even brought to nearly zero. Peace will be restored in my country and the spread of HIV/AIDS due to idleness will also be reduced. This can only be achieved when at least, 80% of Nigerian women, youths and disable persons are gainfully employed and has the capacity to employ others, the achievement of a crime free and peaceful society will be actualized, while the spread of HIV/AIDS will also reduce.
    To achieve this, regular seminars, sensitization programmes and workshops about the empowerments of women, youths and disabled persons is needed.
    Empowering beneficiaries, going by the fact that 90% of what leads the women and youths to crimes is idleness and quest for a better livelihood. Where the women and youth cannot find any good thing to lay hands on, they will likely result to follow evil/ bad direction. EEYEF is working on establishing these women, youths and disabled persons for a better tomorrow through this good initiative and encourages them to learn any of the below listed vocational jobs.
    The vocational skills the beneficiaries will learn are as follows:
    • Hair Dressing = Hair Making, Platting of hair, manicure and Pedicure etc.
    • Auto Mechanic =Vulcanizing, Panel beating and painting, Car Furniture
    • Auto Electrician and Battery Charging
    • Wood Works = Furniture Making etc.
    • Electrician= Repairs of air conditioners, refrigerators
    • Welding/ fabrication
    • Cobbling
    • Barbing
    • Aluminum works/ fabrication
    • Sowing /Tailoring (fashion designing)
    • Making of Snacks (Confectionaries)
    • Soap making
    • Dying of cloths
    • Making of hats
    We are pleading for your assistance to help us empower the candidates who are beneficiaries to EEYEF empowerment initiative. Remember, that why it is necessary and important for us to strive to empower these women and youths to stop crime is because “crime is like stray bullet no one knows who will be a victim to it.” “CRIME IS CRIME AND MUST BE STOPPED”.
    Understand that training without empowering beneficiaries is like empowering them to be violent or use the acquired skills negatively. This is because when they are not empowered; they will use their talents negatively. Our only source of funds for now is from the royalties gotten from the sale of the novels published by the founder of this foundation titled “The Unknown God”, “Cruel Destiny” and others.
    Right now, the founder of this foundation has released another book, this time, a Christian book titled “Sermon On Love” and about bringing out two more books titled “Understanding The Ten Commandments” and “The Word of God, Open Cheque to Believers”. He has instructed that none of these books should be sold, rather, it should be shared in churches and Christian religious organizations free and anyone whom is touched to assist should do so through the bank account at the back page as we believe that God will make a name for Himself through the vision of the books and in promoting the gospel. We can send the books to you electronically or by post, though we believe sending it electronically will help you produce as many as possible and make it reach more people.
    We also plead that you help introduce us to other corporate bodies, religious organizations, public spirited individuals, charity organization, multi-national corporations to come to our aid. The amount needed to carry out this humanitarian job in this perspective is huge.
    We are pleading for your assistance to help us empower the candidates who are beneficiaries to EEYEF empowerment initiative. Remember, that why it is necessary and important for us to strive to empower these women and youths to stop crime is because crime is like stray bullet no one knows who will be a victim to it. “CRIME IS CRIME AND MUST BE STOPPED”.
    Understand that training without empowering beneficiaries is like empowering them to be violent or use the acquired skills negatively. This is because where they are not empowered; they will use their talents negatively. Our only source of funds for now is from the royalties gotten from the sale of the novels published by our founder titled “The Unknown God”, “Cruel Destiny” and others.
    We are soliciting for your financial/ material assistance to help us achieve this humanitarian work so that we can have a crime free and peaceful society. Also, the spread of HIV/AIDS will be reduced.
    We also plead that you help introduce us to other corporate bodies, religious organizations, public spirited individuals, charity organization, multi-national corporations who we can partner with to come to our aid. The amount needed to carry out this humanitarian job in this perspective is huge.
    Please visit (http://www.crowdrise.com/HopeForAfricanWomenAndYouths/fundraiser/emmaekwonnayouthempo)

    Hoping for a favourable answer.
    Yours Faithfully,
    Esther Chinwendum Nneoma(P.R.O.)
    +234-8098204032

  2. Fatima

    My apologies for the typos in my comment. That auto correct function does more harm than good I’m afraid.

  3. Farima

    forf the Vatican has such articles and has purchased them from sellers who have obtained antiquities, this is a good thing that the Vatican had purchased them to save them for for posterity. If such articles can be identified, it would be fair that Israel purchase them to reimburse the Vatican for having intercepted them andf preserving them. It would be nice if one day a temple museum in Israel could display some of the original implements and art of Temple 1 or Temple 2. It would acknowledge the truth of their history.

  4. Geoffrey Morgan

    When the original Knight Templar returned from Jerusalem they brought back with them huge amounts of gold, silver and Temple artefacts recovered from under Temple Mount. All this treasure was concealed at various locations which were marked using the chess board as a map, each site represented by an effigy of a Knight with characteristics which describe by the appropriate square. Those Knights on black squares are depicted with crossed legs as seen in Temple Church London and also in St Mary’s Church at Aldworth near Newbury, where the nine stone effigies are said to represent the De La Beche family. The same story is told in the Danse Macabre figures in the Lady Chapel at Rosslyn and in the Classical Monuments at Shugborough Hall. The treasures have lain undisturbed since the early twelfth century.

  5. Silverwolf

    I doubt that even the Visigoths got the treasures. Gold was always the best currency in the Roman Empire and I believe that it after being shown for maybe a few years of pride building by the exotic booty they took, Rome needed gold, not relics of religious shrines they had pilfered and maybe after a couple of decades they need coin to pay their armies and mercenaries and their it went.

  6. Ben Beck

    I have always felt the Vatican holds treasures from the 2nd Temple. The Popes for centuries have claimed a connection to the Colosseum and demonstrated this with rituals that continue to this day. Maybe because they paid for it with money they had paid to buy the treasures of the Jewish Temple from the Roman Soldiers. The Vatican’s hidden treasures should be revealed to the world and returned to those they were taken from. Thou shalt not steal. Well Vatican.. those items don’t belong to you. Even if you did pay for them.

  7. mark

    Its known all gold was melted down by one of the Gothic tribes but maybe the Vatican does have the candlestick and I’m sure the Jewish people would love it back

  8. Post
    Author
  9. John

    To Liam, I suggest you recheck your history. The name Vatican has been applied to the specific location now known as the Vatican City since the days of the Roman Republic. As to the location of the Hebrew treasures stolen from the Temple. Since much of it was made of gold, the logical thing was that in one of the centuries following the 70 AD victory of Rome over Judea, the gold was melted down. That was common practice of victors of any war of the period. You took what booty you could from the enemy then you repurposed it. It is just extremely unlikely that any of it survived the many times in the ensuing centuries that the empire or it’s successors were in financial difficulties. The original treasures most likely were melted down as were the later replacements.

  10. Kasia

    Guys, let me say something here as roman catholic. It would be for me hard to believe, that we would find something like the treasures of the Temple – simply because 1) we don’t need them, 2) because our law is to respect our older brothers in faith, Jews, in practicing their faith.
    Now the important part – do you really think the treasures remained in Rome? I think it’s quiet unlikely. Wikipedia says, that “According to Procopius, in 533 Byzantine general Belisarius took the treasures of the Jewish temple from Vandals who had taken them from Rome.” Also read this:
    http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/113199#.VF6PMPmG-AY
    I would very much suppose, the treasures are somewhere in the Middle East (Turkey? Palestinian / Arab territories?). Rome as part of Europe has been examined by archeologists in every single inch I believe. But the Middle East still has some secrets unrevealed.

  11. Pingback: Books: The Columbus Affair | Perennial Student

  12. Liam

    To Oscar “The Romans took everything with them to the Vatican” ???
    I hate break this to you but you are about 330 to 400 years to early. The Vatican did not yet exist, yes St. Peters grave was there at that location but that is it. While standing at Titus Arch looking at the carvings of the seven-branched candlestick, and the silver trumpets all one has to do is turn around and you will see the colosseum. It is a well known fact that loot from Jerusalem was melted down, minted into coin and was used to pay for the construction of the colosseum by Flavian. Please Oscar read up before you make yourself look like a fool and post stuff like that

  13. Cayman

    I think the Vatican should return anything they have belonging to the Jews, but I do believe many of the artifacts, including the Ark of the Covenant, were discovered by Ron Wyatt. I believe that he saw Jesus at the Mount of Olives, and that Jesus was traveling from Africa to the New Jerusalem. Ron Wyatt was also led to the real Mount Sinai and the Red Sea crossing. Constantine’s mother falsified the locations of those locations. Ron Wyatt also found Noah’s Ark. Read how Ron Wyatt told the Jewish people about the Ark of the Covenant. They sent priests from the Levi lineage to get the Ark. They all died. Ron had to put their dead bodies in a basket with a rope on it so that the Jews could remove this. I suppose they want to keep this a secret, but Christians are now the Ark of the Covenant. So I believe that Ron, full of the Holy Spirit, was spared. I believe the Jewish people are aware of the location of the Ark, where it was hidden before Rome plundered them. Ron showed them, but they can’t enter for fear of their lives. Jesus is waiting for His Jewish people to seek Him. So the Vatican might have some things but Ron made a list with diagrams of the articles that he discovered. They were covered in sheepskin, and are under the cross where Jesus was crucified. The earth split and some of blood fell onto the altar as a sacrifice for our sins. Do a search on Ron Wyatt and the Ark. Also found was the Ten Commandments and I believe that he scraped some of the dried blood and had it analyzed. It contained the chromosomes from His mom, but only one chromosome from His Father. I don’t know why the Jewish people never made this information available, except maybe for their pride, that Jesus truly was the Messiah. God Bless.

  14. lenbenheart

    If in fact the Vatican & Rome possess these STOLEN sacred objects: they SHOULD be returned to Israel as soon as possible. Why have then hidden away from view in underground dungeons and vaults.???

  15. Oscar

    The Romans took everything with them to the Vatican. They are thieves, and they will always remain thieves as long as they hold the holy artifacts in their possession.
    They probably melted down all the gold to make adornments for their church. They claim to be the true church, but they are not.
    True Christians, true followers of Christ, Jesus, do not still. Jesus will return, and the Vatican will get on their knees, and the pope too, but it will be too late

  16. Samir S. Halabi

    If the Vatican does hold some of the treasure stolen by the Romans when they sacked Jerusalem and destroyed the 2nd Temple, it should now be all returned to ‘The State of Israel.’
    Rome caused all the suffering, the persecution, the genocide which world Jewry as endured for the last 2,000 years, therefore the Italians through their ancestors are indirectly responsible for what befell the Jews since their forced great dispersion to all the four corners of the world. The vatican has a lot to answer with reference to the 2,000 year old persecution of the jewish people.

  17. lionel french

    This is ironic. It is some years since I wrote to Shimon Shetreet. He never replied. I wrote to the London Ambassy of the State of Israel with information. It was never acknowledged and finally, I wrote to the editor of the Jerusalem post and once again my letter was ignored. What is it with you people that when someone tries to help they are cold shouldered? Certain documents and inscriptions to be found in the village of Rennes-le-Chateau, south of France, suggest that there is, in the area, ‘Sion tresor’. If such is the case, then the question must obviously be asked – how did it get there? One solution is the question could be explained by the establishment of the Visigoth kingdom, following their sacking of Rome in 410. Another could well well be by way of the Templar Knights who had very strong representation in this particular part of France, prior to its Order being dissolved by Philip the Fair who was after their wealth – but never got it.
    Having tried very hard over a period of time by letter writing and being ignored I feel that in order to be more direct in what I claim to understand, I would impose conditions – so would my son who has a PhD in science. The condition has absolutely nothing at all with money – or reward. Absolutely not. My wish is to see the Menorah returned to Jerusalem and placed in the Israeli seat of government – the Knesset, in the absence of the temple on the Temple Mount.
    Now, I don’t know who you are but, I will say this, if your article is just a news item then do not bother to respond to this. If however, your voice is heard in the Knesset, then I would wish to have your remarks concerning your position, at a national level, before I release any information to you. The condition I would make for myself, and that of my son, would be that you pay our expenses to visit and stay in the area of France – having obtained permission from the Authority for Ancient Monuments to archaeologically investigate the site I would take you to. It is the ruin of a building – a very old building. However, I suspect that this will be the last we shall hear from you. Interestingly, the Menorah is referred to by name but, in addition it is also spoken of as Lampes, OIE (Goose if you are schooled in the fables of Aesop, the Ord Orme (gold tree/elm) and finally, OR LUX. There is just one more thing; do not waste my time. If you are interested but have not authority, I do not wish to hear from you. If you claim to have authority, then you will be required to prove it and I would want to see government interet, serious intention in the matter, supported in writing, complete with a senior government’s signature applied to the paper bearing the official seal of Israel – the Menorah.

  18. David Moray

    We have always known that the Vatican has artifacts from the Second Temple. When I heard that the Pope declared that, “….the Jews did not kill Jesus…” I said to myself, “Great!, now just give us back our stuff!”

  19. Ruby Sanchez

    The Vatican should give up the goods. After all this time it seems only fair. I mean, really, who owns anything. The Vatican probably has them in a crate in a basement. Let’s get them out in the open for everyone to enjoy. Roman Catholics, Jewish and the like. We can learn so much from history and from one another.

  20. Post
    Author
    smoothstone

    I find it difficult to believe that posters like Simon, aka ReginaLady, never learned that proper names, like Roman and Jewish and The Vatican, should be capitalized. But then again, education is just another myth to rile up the uneducated.

  21. Simon

    I find it difficult to believe that the vatican would have the temple artifacts or that the romans would hold onto them.
    They were proably melted down long ago for some roman purpose.
    The Temple Artifacts still being around is just another myth to rile up the jewish people.

  22. John Anderson

    I fully agree with Ann, in that there are numerous cases throughout the years, of countries petitioning others for the rightful return of plundered, stolen and smuggled artifacts. One that comes to mind, recently and continuously, is Zahi Hawass, on behalf of the Egyptian Antiquities services. I beleive that several countries have to date, agreed with Mr. Hawass on this very subject, and have returned, and or are in negotiations, concerning the return of important Egyptian treasures. NO, the Vatican should not receive any special treatment.

  23. Ann

    I believe the Vatican should return all artifacts and documents to their proper homes as can be resonably asserted. I know that they have pre-Columbian art in their archives from the Americas. Also, countless documents had been confiscated from the Jews during the Inquisition which would help in identifying those who are crypto Jews. I don’t see why the Vatican gets a pass on confiscated articles when countries and races have been sucessful in establishing ownership of items confiscated by others – such as the Nazis.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *